A comprehensive guide to help you choose the best solution for your bathroom.
There are several methods for addressing an ugly bathtub and/or shower enclosure, with the most common being refinishing, replacement, and bathtub or shower liners. Each of these approaches has its own advantages and drawbacks, depending on your goals, budget, and the condition of your existing tub.
Bathtub Refinishing versus Liners or Replacement
| Comparison | Refinishing | Liners | Replacement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aesthetics (Look & Feel) | Like New | Often feels “spongy” to touch | Like New |
| Longevity | 5-10 years | 5-10 years | 15-30 years |
| Timeline | 1 Day | 1-2 Days (not counting measuring & ordering time) | 2 Days to Weeks |
| Design Options | Unlimited Colors | Limited Colors | Many Options |
| COSTS $$$ | $400 to $800 | $3000 & up | $2500 & up |
Bathtub Refinishing
Bathtub refinishing, also known as reglazing or resurfacing, involves repairing the surface of your existing tub and applying a new coating to make it look brand new. The process typically includes cleaning, sanding, and patching any cracks, followed by spraying on a new layer of durable enamel or urethane.
The entire process can be completed within a day, and your bathtub is usually ready for use within 24 hours.
Pros
- Cost-Effective: Refinishing is much more affordable than replacing a tub, often costing between $400 to $800.
- Aesthetic Flexibility: You can change the color and finish of your tub to match your bathroom’s new design. Unlimited possibilities in color and tiles can be infused with textures.
- Structural: Professional refinishing can correct cracks, blemishes, worn spots, broken or cracked tiles and more.
Cons
- Longevity: The refinishing surface may last 10 to 15 years but requires proper care and maintenance. It’s not as durable as a new tub.
Bathtub Liners
(Bathtub Liners, Shower Enclosure Liners)
Tub liners are custom-made acrylic or PVC shells that fit over your existing tub. They’re often installed by professional contractors and provide a quick fix without removing the old tub. Tub liners can usually be installed in a day or two, with minimal disruption.
Liners don’t provide the smooth, original feel of a new or refinished bathtub surface. Many users report a spongy sensation when touching the liner.
Pros
- Quick Installation: Tub liners can usually be installed in a day or two, with minimal disruption.
- Non-Invasive: Since no demolition is involved, your existing plumbing and tiles can remain intact.
Cons
- Fit Issues: Improperly installed liners can lead to water trapping between the liner and the tub, causing mold and mildew problems. Any gap can exacerbate the “spongy” feel when using the tub or shower.
- Limited Design Options: You have fewer choices when it comes to colors and finishes compared to refinishing or replacement.
- High Cost: If you opt for anything above a simple bathtub liner, you may be in for sticker shock. These companies that advertise “one day bath remodel” commonly upsell by charging for every feature. The average cost of $3,000 can easily go up to $10k or more.
Replacement
(bathtub or shower enclosure)
Replacing a bathtub involves removing the old one and installing a new model. It’s a more involved process that may also require modifications to plumbing, tiling, and walls. Most people don’t realize that professionals will also charge for demolition as it is often the old tub can’t just be carried out through the door.
Pros
- Durability: A brand-new tub will likely last for decades, providing long-term peace of mind.
- Customization: You have the option to completely change the size, shape, material, and style of your tub.
Cons
- Disruptive: The process can take several days or even weeks, leaving your bathroom unusable during that time.
- High Cost: Replacing a bathtub can cost anywhere from $2,500 to $5,000 or more, especially if it requires additional work on plumbing or tile.
Which method is right for you?
- Budget: If you’re looking for a cost-effective solution, refinishing will be your best option. Refinishing is unbeatable in terms of cost savings.
- Durability: If you want a long-term fix and don’t mind the higher cost and disruption, a replacement may be a better choice.
- Aesthetics: For maximum design flexibility, replacement or refinishing (with custom color choices) gives you more options than a liner.
- Convenience: Refinishing and tub liners are both fast processes with minimal disruption, whereas replacement takes much longer.
Bathtub Refinishing versus Liners or Replacement – The Bottom Line
Each method has its own unique benefits, but refinishing strikes a balance between affordability, convenience, and aesthetics. It’s a great option if your tub needs a refresh or to bring your old tub/shower in line with an updated bathroom remodel.
Maryland Tub & Tile specializes in bathtub and shower refinishing, offering an affordable and efficient solution to restore the look of worn-out bathroom surfaces. This method saves homeowners the time and expense of full replacements while extending the life of existing fixtures. With a focus on quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction, Maryland Tub & Tile is licensed and insured providing a written guarantee for every project.
